PeopleScout U.S. Jobs Report Analysis — February 2019

The Labor Department released its February jobs report which shows that U.S. employers added 20,000 jobs in February, well below analyst expectations. The unemployment rate decreased to 3.8 percent last month. Year-over-year wage growth increased to 3.4 percent, the best rate in a decade. U.S. employers have added to payrolls for 101 straight months, extending the longest continuous jobs expansion on record.

OVERALL Overall Jobs Added: 20,000 Overall Unemployment Rate: 3.8 percent (Down Arrow) Overall Wage Change: + 3.4 percent (Up Arrow) INDUSTRY BREAKDOWN (Table B-1 for Job Changes) (Table B-3 to calculate hourly wage change) Financial Description of Industry: The financial industry includes financial, insurance and real estate employers. Jobs Change: +6,000 Hourly Wage Change: +3.8 percent Manufacturing Description of Industry: The manufacturing industry includes employers who produce both durable and non-durable goods. Jobs Change: +4,000 Hourly Wage Change: +2.0 percent Transportation and Warehousing Description of Industry: The transportation and warehousing industry includes air, ground and water transportation of passengers and goods, pipeline transportation and warehouse and storage. Jobs Change: -3,000 Hourly Wage Change: +1.4 percent Retail Description of Industry Category: The retail industry includes motor vehicle, home furnishings, electronics, health, clothing and other retail businesses. Jobs Change: -6,100 Hourly Wage Change: +5.0 percent Education and Health Services Description of Industry Category: The education and health services industry includes education, healthcare and social assistance. Jobs Change: +4,000 Hourly Wage Change: +2.9 percent Leisure and Hospitality Description of Industry Category: The leisure and hospitality industry includes arts and entertainment, accommodation and food and beverage service organizations. Jobs Change: +0 Hourly Wage Change: +4.1 percent Professional and Business Services Description of Industry Category: The professional and business services industry includes jobs in waste management, administrative and support services and professional positions in the legal, accounting, computer and advertising fields. Jobs Change: +42,000 Hourly Wage Change: +3.3 percent Observations U.S. employers added 20,000 jobs in January, which fell far short of analyst expectations. The unemployment rate decreased to 3.8 percent in February. Year-over-year wage growth grew to 3.4 percent, which is the best rate in a decade. U.S. employers have added to payrolls for 101 straight months, extending the longest continuous jobs expansion on record.

The Numbers

20,000: The economy added 20,000 jobs in February.

3.8%: The unemployment decreased to 3.8 percent.

3.4%: Wages increased to a rate of 3.4 percent growth over the last year.

The Good

Despite the low number of new payrolls added, the historic job creation streak continued. The change in total nonfarm payroll employment for December was revised up to +227,000, and the change for January was revised up to +311,000. After revisions, job gains have averaged 186,000 per month over the last 3 months.

The unemployment rate declined by 0.2 percentage points to 3.8 percent in February, and the number of unemployed persons decreased by 300,000 to 6.2 million. Among the unemployed, the number of job losers and those who completed temporary jobs (including people on temporary layoff) declined by 225,000. This decline reflects, at least in part, in part, the return of federal workers who were furloughed in January due to the partial government shutdown. Those workers who were working part-time jobs for economic reasons are now in full-time positions. As one economist put it, “They now have paychecks and don’t need to drive Uber to make ends meet.”

A comprehensive unemployment rate that counts discouraged workers as well as those holding jobs part time for economic reasons, which is often called the “real” unemployment rate, fell to 7.3 percent in February from 8.1 percent in January.

The year-over-year wage increase of 3.4 percent is well above the rate of inflation. The result will likely result in more consumer spending that helps fuel the American economy.

The Bad

February’s report shows the weakest job growth since September 2017. While there are one-time factors such as the partial government shutdown and record cold temperatures in much of the country which may have contributed to the modest growth, it could also be an indicator of a slowdown in the job market in the coming months, the New York Times reports.

“With a single report, the six-month average rate of job growth has fallen to 190,000 from 234,000. That lower number is a better fit with everything else we know about the state of the economy — particularly a 3.8 percent unemployment rate and lots of anecdotal reports of scarce workers. Businesses can’t add people to the payrolls who don’t exist.

Add in the ample evidence that the overall rate of growth is shifting down as trade wars continue to disrupt industries and as the impact of tax cuts fade, and a more modest rate of job creation makes sense.

So job growth in the sub-200,000-a-month range seems a lot more plausible for the rest of 2019 — and yet more deceleration is a strong possibility.”

The Unknown

How significant is February’s weak jobs report? Many analysts caution that one report does not provide a clear indicator of long-term trends:

“Mark Hamrick, senior economic analyst at, said “slowing job growth is to be expected over the coming year, one way or the other,” but blamed much of the February shortfall on a seasonal hiring slowdown in the construction and leisure and hospitality sectors.

“It is fodder for a reminder that we cannot assume too much about a single monthly report.”

While the economic significance of the February report remains to be seen, some analysts argue that the overall fundamentals of the American economy remain strong and therefore this weak jobs report could essentially be an outlier:

“One month does not a trend make, and the United States economy remains very robust, especially when compared with sluggish Europe and slowing China. Oil prices are falling, which helps all sectors of the economy except, of course, oil. And while the trade deficit reached a record in 2018, that is a sign of strength not weakness.  Exports rose sharply, but imports rose even more, thanks to the booming American economy. And, by definition, capital inflows must offset trade deficits, so a lot of foreigners think the United States is a great place to invest.”

Having been surprised by the details of February’s report, those with a stake in the US and world economy may be anticipating the results of next month’s report with an eagerness they have not felt in years.

By | 2019-03-08T15:12:30+00:00 March 8th, 2019|