AI in Recruiting: A Handbook for Talent Acquisition Leaders

Posted on November 4, 2025November 4, 2025 by akessler

Artificial intelligence (AI) has captured attention across nearly every industry for its seemingly boundless potential to transform how work gets done—including AI in recruiting. Yet for many talent acquisition (TA) leaders, AI remains shrouded in hype, myths and even fear that “robot recruiters” are taking over.

This handbook sets out to demystify AI tools for recruitment with facts about real-world applications across talent acquisition capabilities and provide guidance on how talent teams can start planning to use AI effectively and ethically. We’ll cut through the hype to bring AI down to earth—focusing on what works, not what’s flashy.

The message we want to reinforce upfront is that AI should not be seen as a replacement for the talent acquisition strategy you’ve already built, but rather a set of tools to make your teams better at tasks both mundane and meaningful.

📌 Before we go any further, here’s a note from our legal team:

The information provided in this article does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal or other professional advice; instead, all information, content, and materials available in this article are for general information purposes only. Readers of this article should contact their attorney or legal advisor to obtain advice with respect to any particular legal matter. No reader of this article should act or refrain from acting on the basis of information in this article without first seeking legal advice from counsel in the relevant jurisdiction. All liability with respect to actions taken or not taken based on the contents of this article are expressly disclaimed by PeopleScout, Inc.. The content in this article is provided “as-is”, and no representations are made by PeopleScout that the content is error-free.

What is AI?

The term artificial intelligence or AI was coined by Stanford Professor John McCarthy, who defined it as “the science and engineering of making intelligent machines, especially intelligent computer programs.” AI is technology with the ability to perform tasks that would otherwise require human intelligence. Data and algorithms enable AI to “learn” how to accomplish complex tasks without being explicitly programmed to do them. It also includes the sub-fields of machine learning, speech and natural language processing and robotic process automation.

Over the last decade, AI capabilities have advanced tremendously due to increases in computing power, the abundance of digital data and improvements in machine learning algorithms. As a result, AI solutions can now match or even outperform humans in certain tasks related to object recognition, language processing, prediction modelling and more.

It is critical to distinguish between two key forms: Predictive AI (Classic Machine Learning) and Generative AI (Large Language Models). Understanding this difference is the foundation of a modern AI strategy.

Predictive AI (Classic Machine Learning)

This is the traditional form of AI that has driven recruiting technology for the last decade. It uses historical data to make analysis, classification, and prediction. Its primary function is to score, filter, and identify patterns.

Focus	Function in Recruiting	Examples
Analysis	Scoring candidate fit based on historical success data.	Skills-based matching; Candidate ranking and scoring; Predicting early attrition risk.
Classification	Grouping and categorizing unstructured data.	Clustering résumés and CVs by required skills; Categorizing sentiment from employee feedback forms.
Prediction	Forecasting outcomes based on training data.	Predicting time-to-hire; Calculating accurate market-based salary bands.

Generative AI (Gen AI) and Large Language Models (LLMs)

The disruption delivered by generative AI meant that AI went from an abstract concept to a tangible force radically impacting businesses—and jobs—worldwide. Instead of predicting a score, it excels at synthesis, creation, and conversation. Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, Google Gemini and Microsoft Copilot, are the engines of Gen AI, taking AI from expensive and exclusive to an everyday tool accessible by the masses.

Focus	Function in Recruiting	Examples
Synthesis	Creating coherent, human-like output from input prompts.	Drafting job descriptions and interview scripts; Summarizing interview notes; Auditing JDs for inaccessible language.
Conversation	Interacting with users through natural language.	Intelligent chatbots handling candidate FAQs; Creating personalized outreach based on a candidate’s public profile.

The Future: AI Agents

The most significant development in recent years is Agentic AI. Incorporating machine learning, LLMs and predictive analytics, Agentic AI systems are designed to act autonomously to achieve specific goals, executing multi-step processes without continuous human intervention—unlike traditional pre-programmed chatbots.

Agentic AI can support:

Recruiter support: Beyond basic automation, AI Agents act as a proactive partner for recruiters, surfacing critical insights, predicting candidate behavior and identifying emerging trends, allowing them to focus on strategic, high-value activities like relationship building and complex negotiations. It provides information needed for better decision-making through real-time analytics and predictive capabilities, while ensuring compliance and reducing potential bias.
Dynamic personalization: Agentic AI autonomously tailors content and communications to each candidate based on their real-time browsing behavior, past interactions and career interests.
Proactive engagement: By analyzing candidate data and behavior patterns, AI agents can anticipate needs and independently initiate relevant support or information sharing, while understanding candidate intentions and emotions.
Question handling: Agentic AI elevates self-service capabilities by managing FAQs and knowledge bases, searching across multiple databases to resolve queries—all while continuously learning from interactions. It also audits content for accuracy and compliance while suggesting improvements to the knowledge base.
Anticipating candidate needs: Through analysis of historical and real-time data, agentic AI predicts candidate behavior trends, helping recruiters address needs more efficiently and identify candidates at risk of dropping out. The AI agent can even independently put at-risk candidates into a re-engagement campaign.

The State of AI in Recruiting

Top talent has become increasingly scarce and competitive, while recruiting resources and budgets remain strained. This situation demands that talent acquisition teams work smarter, and AI and automation could represent an opportunity for organizations to enhance human capabilities in recruitment.

According to Gartner, a massive 81% of HR leaders have explored or implemented AI solutions to improve process efficiency within their organization. HR leaders aim to use generative AI (Gen AI) for improving efficiency in HR processes (63%), enhancing the employee experience (52%) and bolstering learning and development programs. Plus, 76% of HR leaders believe that if their organization does not adopt AI solutions in the next year or two, they will lag behind those that do.

Sign up for our Talking Talent Newsletter

Get PeopleScout’s insights sent directly to your inbox

What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of AI in Recruitment?

While AI holds tremendous promise, it also comes with some real concerns which talent acquisition and HR leaders must thoughtfully address. AI is largely unregulated and has received criticism for negative impacts on things like privacy, security, bias, and transparency in its decision-making processes. However, with care and diligence, you can establish sensible guidelines at your organization, so this technology enhances your talent acquisition capabilities while respecting human values.

Benefits of AI for Recruiting

AI can help the humans behind your talent program work more efficiently and effectively when used correctly. Applying AI across the various recruiting stages introduces a host of benefits, including:

Efficiency
AI-powered tools can shoulder time-consuming tasks like communications and initial screening, allowing recruiters to reach more candidates at scale. AI systems help recruiters to focus their efforts on the most promising prospects, including helping identify passive candidates. This wider reach improves quality by putting recruiters in front of more qualified candidates.
Improved Candidate Experience
Tools like AI chatbots and self-scheduling create a seamless 24/7 candidate experience. By fielding frequently asked questions and coordinating interviews, they dramatically reduce time-to-hire. Candidates get quick responses instead of waiting for recruiters to come online, making the hiring process faster and frictionless.
Improved Matching
Advanced AI algorithms surface qualified prospects that may have been overlooked. By analyzing candidates’ skills, experience, and other attributes and matching them to open roles, AI systems ensure better candidate-job fit. This improves quality-of-hire and unlocks hidden talent pools recruiters may have missed.
Enhanced Diversity and Inclusion
With the right data to learn from, AI reduces unconscious bias from hiring by focusing decisions on data rather than gut instinct. By objectively evaluating candidates’ skills without prejudice, AI-assisted recruiting enhances diversity and creates a more equitable hiring process.
Cost Reduction
AI can reduce the cost-per-applicant in some cases. Recruiters can outsource low-impact, repetitive tasks to AI, and spend more time interacting with candidates and hiring managers. This optimization of talent acquisition teams enables resources to be allocated more efficiently, reducing vacancy rates and lowering costs.

Risks of AI in Recruiting

While AI offers immense efficiency, its integration introduces specific compliance, ethical, and data integrity risks that require robust organizational governance. The regulatory landscape is complex and constantly evolving, meaning organizations must adopt a proactive, audit-ready stance.

PeopleScout POV

PeopleScout is committed to striking the right balance between next-generation technology and maintaining the trust we’ve built with candidates and clients. As our clients’ trusted talent advisors, we do our due diligence and work touphold our standards for quality and compliance when helping clients adopt new technologies like GenAI.

Regulatory Landscape

The trend in global regulation is to classify AI tools used in core HR and talent acquisition as “high-risk” systems, requiring greater scrutiny. Regulations like the EU AI Act indicate a clear direction: AI systems that materially impact employment outcomes (screening, ranking, decision support) require high levels of transparency, data quality, and human oversight. Specific regional laws, such as New York City’s Local Law 144, require independent, annual bias audits of Automated Employment Decision Tools (AEDTs) and public disclosure of their usage. These localized laws set a precedent for transparency that organizations should anticipate across all operating regions.

To navigate this, organizations should consider establishing a formal AI Governance Framework:

AI Ethics Committee: A cross-functional group (HR, Legal, Tech) responsible for approving AI use cases.
Continuous Auditability: Mechanisms to constantly monitor models for drift and bias after deployment.
Human-in-the-Loop: Clear protocols defining when a human expert must review and override an AI decision before final action is taken.

Hallucination

Gen AI’s ability to create plausible-sounding content can lead to a risk known as hallucination—when the model produces false, misleading or unfounded information. All AI-generated content used in external candidate communications must be subjected to a human fact-checking process before deployment.

Data Privacy and Personal Identifiable Information (PII)

The volume of data handled by recruiting AI exposes organizations to significant data privacy risks under regimes like GDPR and CCPA. Feeding Personal Identifiable Information (PII) or confidential company data into public, external LLMs poses a severe risk of data leakage and non-compliance.

To reduce this risk, organizations should adhere to strict data minimization principles, collecting and retaining data that is absolutely necessary. For training internal AI models, best practice involves anonymization techniques to scrub training data of PII and protected characteristics before it is consumed by the AI system.

Algorithmic Bias

AI models are trained on historical data, which can inherently reflect past biases in hiring practices. For example, if an AI model is trained on a dataset where, historically, male candidates were disproportionately hired for certain roles, the AI will learn to associate male-leaning language or experience with higher success, thereby reinforcing and even amplifying that bias in future decisions.

By implementing audit processes and continuous monitoring, organizations can actively measure and course-correct algorithmic bias throughout the candidate lifecycle, moving toward measurable fairness.

Disproportionate Impact

Certain demographic groups face higher exposure to the potential harms of AI in recruitment. For instance, if an AI screening system relies heavily on standardized test scores that have racial biases, it could automatically filter out qualified minority candidates. Similarly, lower income communities may lack access to the digital tools and internet connectivity required for AI screening. This digital divide could automatically exclude qualified candidates from disadvantaged backgrounds.

Without proactive measures to address these systemic issues, AI recruitment tools risk amplifying real-world inequality. Organizations must consider disproportionate impact with their use of AI in order to improve diversity and reinforce equity.

Lack of Transparency

Organizations may experience resistance amongst candidates and employees when there is a lack of understanding of how AI is being used in the hiring process and how AI arrives at certain outputs or recommendations.

You can nurture trust through training and effective communication to help recruiters, hiring managers and applicants understand the reasons behind AI-generated outcomes and their role in the hiring decision-making process. Use clear and understandable language to describe the factors influencing decisions and put mechanisms in place to capture feedback and reporting of potential issues. Transparency promotes ethical AI use in recruitment and also reinforces organizational values and establishes a positive reputation in the industry.

Data from Pew Research Center shows that 61% of Americans are unaware that employers are currently using AI in the hiring process. A majority (71%) oppose AI making a final hiring decision, while 41% oppose AI being used to review applications. However, the more people understand about AI, the more they’re in favor of its use in the recruitment process. For example, 43% of those who’ve heard a lot about using AI in the hiring process support its use for reviewing applications, compared with 37% who’ve heard a little and 21% who’ve heard nothing at all.

Over-Automation

Heavy reliance on AI also poses risks if the recruitment process becomes overly automated and fails to incorporate sound human judgment as a check. Too much automated communication can feel depersonalized to a candidate. AI should never replace the human touch—rather it should enhance human capabilities. Plus, companies using AI for recruitment must ensure compliance with all relevant regulations. For example, under GDPR, there are strict guidelines around automated decision-making, and individuals have the right to obtain human intervention and contest automated decisions that significantly affect them.

👉 Learn the dos and don’ts of automating the candidate experience.

Proactively addressing these concerns through governance, oversight and continuous improvement of AI systems and processes is key to managing the risks responsibly. Overall, the use of AI in recruitment is permitted but becoming more and more tightly regulated. Systems cannot make final hiring decisions and must be transparent, fair and accountable. Adhering to data protection laws and anti-discrimination regulations is crucial for the ethical use of AI in hiring. Undergoing regular audits to assess for unintended bias and maintaining the human touch to review, override or contest automated recommendations is crucial.

📌 We recommend you consult your legal team before implementing any AI technologies at your organization.

Use Cases for AI in Recruitment

As recruiting grows more competitive, organizations are turning to smart technologies to gain an edge in attracting and engaging candidates. From chatbots to video interviews and skills assessments, AI-powered solutions are streamlining efficiencies while enabling deeper insights across the hiring funnel. Here are some examples demonstrating AI’s immense potential to boost recruiting outcomes while improving the candidate experience.

👉 Learn how to build the ultimate recruitment tech stack.

How to Use AI for Candidate Attraction and Sourcing

Identifying, contacting and engaging prospective candidates is ripe for AI augmentation. Building a robust pipeline of talent typically involves highly manual, repetitive tasks that can divert focus away from higher-value tasks. Here are some of the ways AI can support you in filling your recruitment funnel.

Building Candidate Personas

AI can pull from the profiles of existing employees and historical hiring data for a given role to surface patterns and common characteristics. These patterns, combined with qualitative data gathered from interviews, can help you to define a persona profile of the ideal candidate for the role.

A persona is a fictional character profile that represents the different types of candidates who would be successful in a role. Personas focus on individual characteristics, behaviors, interests, goals, motivators and challenges. With these in place, you can create alignment across your recruitment and sourcing strategies. Your persona profiles should provide specific guidance about how to find candidates who fit the profile, including targeted messages that will resonate.

👉 Learn more about how to build candidate personas.

Writing Job Descriptions

Since launching in late 2022, ChatGPT and other Gen AI tools, like Claude, Gemini and more, quickly permeated the workplace. These tools mimic human communication and can help with everything from content creation and market analysis to simply writing emails. They can also be used to write job descriptions.

By feeding them with relevant prompts that detail the job tasks and required skills as well as employer brand elements like tone of voice, Gen AI can produce a first draft job description in seconds. The hiring manager and recruiter can then massage this text to create the final posting.

For existing job descriptions, AI can be used to measure sentiment and detect biased language. Recruiters can instruct Gen AI to explicitly audit an existing JD against a checklist of exclusion criteria. For instance, a prompt might include: “Review this job description and remove all hyper-masculine phrasing, ensuring the required experience is capped at five years. Output the revised text and a list of removed words.”

Job postings with gender-neutral wording get 42% more applications.

Skills Matching

AI is shifting the focus from historical job titles and degrees toward verifiable, current skills, fostering a more equitable and dynamic screening process. AI helps organizations maintain a constantly evolving skills ontology—a structured, hierarchical map of all skills required across the business.

Previously a manual process, AI can sift through a huge number of online profiles to find candidates with the skills you’re looking for. For example, the AI-powered Affinix CRM tool in PeopleScout’s total talent suite Affinix^® searches millions of online profiles to find passive candidates with the skills and competencies that match the role. The AI also assesses the likelihood of a candidate being open to a new opportunity by combining the average tenure of each job listed on their profile with the average aggregate tenure of all other candidates in that same role.

Manually identifying passive candidates who have similar titles but may not be actively searching for a job can take hours of dedicated time. AI can reduce manual efforts and massively speed up the recruitment process. Plus, it helps you concentrate on skills, rather than experience, to expand your candidate pool.

Predictive Analytics

Machine learning models can also provide predictive and prescriptive hiring recommendations based on a candidate’s profile. AI can assess genuine interest, candidate motivations, likelihood to accept an offer and even risk of early turnover. This empowers recruiters to be more informed for interview prep and can help them personalize outreach messages and retention and onboarding strategies to appeal specifically to what matters most for each candidate.

Over time as engagement data is captured, AI models continue to improve, learning what messages and channels persuade candidates with various profiles and career trajectories. This creates a positive feedback loop, compounding efficiencies over each recruiting cycle.

👉 Learn more about predictive analytics in talent acquisition

Internal Mobility and Career Pathing

AI models match current employee skills and inferred career aspirations against open roles, development programs, and adjacent teams. This enables better utilization of existing talent and proactive identification of candidates for internal promotion, significantly boosting retention and reducing external recruiting costs.

How to Use AI for Candidate Screening & Interview Support

Manual candidate screening based on résumés and CVs alone can be an imperfect, biased exercise. With AI lending a “second pair of eyes,” you can ensure quality candidates are not being overlooked. Here are some elements of the process that AI can enhance.

First Sift

Natural language processing tools can ingest thousands of résumés and CVs, and analyze the content, context, and trends across the talent pool within seconds. AI maps candidate experience and skills not just against the job description keywords, but against this deeper, comprehensive skills ontology. This approach reduces reliance on potentially biased proxies (like university pedigree or irrelevant prior job titles), leading to more diverse and qualified shortlists.

Look for tools with a dashboard that highlights the “cream of the crop” candidates that demonstrate the closest alignment, enabling you to reach out or pass the most promising applicants to hiring managers quickly.

Real-Time Screening

Intelligent chatbots, like text and SMS screening tools, create a conversational experience for candidates using natural language processing. These mobile-friendly, text interview tools automatically screen candidates using predetermined questions that gauge their interest and qualifications. Based on the responses, the chatbot can instantly determine the next step for each specific candidate.

👉 Get the best practice guide for texting in recruitment.

Skills Assessments

AI is also leveraged for pre-employment assessments. New tech platforms can test and measure candidates for skills mastery, personality traits, and cognitive abilities to ensure qualified candidates are advancing through the recruitment process. All results should be reviewed by a human to ensure compliance with relevant regulations around automated decision-making. Leveraging AI in skills assessment helps ensure recruiters and hiring managers can focus on priority candidates most likely to succeed in the role, increasing equity along the way.

Want to learn more about how AI can boost your recruitment processes?

Let’s Connect

How to Use AI for Candidate Engagement

AI-powered candidate engagement tools help you create seamless, personalized experiences at scale—boosting candidate satisfaction, accelerating the hiring process and freeing up recruiters to focus on relationship building—where they add the most value.

Personalized Candidate Communications

For several years now, organizations have been leveraging candidate relationship management (CRM) technology to automate communications with candidates throughout the hiring journey. With Gen AI you can craft entire candidate communication journeys tailored to the individual’s profile, the specific stage in the funnel, and the tone of the hiring manager. Combined with automated email drip campaign functionality in the CRM, you can deliver the right information at the right stage in the journey to keep candidates informed of next steps and engaged with content that is relevant to them.

👉 Learn how to get the most out of your CRM.

More recently, recruiters are using Gen AI platforms to help them with drafting one-off emails to candidates. Leveraging the appropriate prompts, a recruiter can get a first draft from ChatGPT which they can then review and edit to fit for specific candidates. This has the potential to save hours’ worth of work each week for your talent acquisition team.

Chatbots & Conversational AI

Chatbots leverage natural language processing to manage various high-volume, repetitive inquiries from candidates. Whether answering frequently asked questions (FAQs) about application status, the interview process, the company or the job role, chatbots provide consistent, accurate responses 24/7—especially relevant when recruiters aren’t working. This improves candidate satisfaction while enabling recruiters to focus on higher-value activities.

Intelligent messaging platforms can initiate one-way communications at scale to nurture candidates. Using data on the prospect, role, process stage and more, AI dynamically generate personalized, thoughtful messages. This level of personalization improves candidate engagement, advances candidates quicker through the funnel and strengthens employment brand affinity.

Modern Conversational AI (upgraded from simple chatbots) can handle multi-modal interactions (text, voice) and take direct action in backend systems. For example, a prompt of, “Schedule an interview with Sarah for the earliest slot next week,” results in the AI checking Sarah’s and the manager’s calendars and booking the meeting directly in the ATS or calendar system.

👉 Learn more about using chatbots in recruiting.

Self-Scheduling Tools

Calendar management bots can take over the time-consuming back-and-forth of scheduling interviews, assessments, site visits and more. By integrating with hiring manager calendars, only convenient time slots are shown to candidates. Candidates automatically receive confirmations and reminders, eliminating this task for recruiters and increasing the likelihood of candidates attending interviews.

How to Get Started with AI in Recruiting

Your steps into AI should focus on exploration rather than big integrations. AI in recruitment is fast-moving and receiving more and more scrutiny from law makers, and an RPO (recruitment process outsourcing) partner can act as a strategic advisor on your AI recruiting journey. RPOs have experience implementing recruitment tech like AI software for clients and can advise on the best options for your needs, integration requirements, data needs, ethical usage, and workflow design.

By leveraging RPO expertise, companies can effectively implement AI-enhanced hiring with less disruption and a faster return on investment. Look for a partner that is moving at your speed when it comes to AI in recruiting. They’ll help you identify areas for quick wins, and help you expand this success through experimentation and testing.

👉 Learn how PeopleScout helped this manufacturing company create a tech-powered, streamlined recruitment process.

Here are some ways an RPO partner can help your explore AI for recruitment:

Change Management:
RPOs can ease the transition to automated processes and drive adoption through training and ongoing support. They can also develop training programs to upskill your in-house recruiters on using AI tools effectively and ethically in accordance with your internal AI policies.
Process Design:
RPOs can redesign recruitment workflows to integrate AI tools. For example, PeopleScout’s Talent Diagnostic examines your talent lifecycle, evaluating your employer brand and your attraction strategy, as well as looking for ways to optimize the candidate experience through technology usage.
Ongoing Optimization:
RPOs can continuously monitor and evaluate AI outputs and fine-tune processes. These insights will help you improve outcomes over time.
Compliance Monitoring:
RPOs stay current on regulations affecting AI in recruiting to advise on lawful and ethical usage in conjunction with your internal legal team.

AI in Recruiting: Potential and Responsibility

AI has demonstrated tremendous potential to transform talent acquisition. As this handbook outlines, it’s no longer just hype, rather it’s delivering real impact across sourcing, screening, interviewing and candidate engagement.

The results you’ll experience from AI depend heavily on factors like data quality, transparency, integration with existing systems and processes, and governance to ensure responsible usage. AI solutions are meant to augment—not replace—the human touch in recruitment. Recruiters are invaluable when it comes to relationship building, coaching and negotiation, and AI can’t replicate what makes them uniquely human.

Looking ahead, the use of AI recruiting technology to connect people to purpose will only continue expanding. Cultivating an ethical, inclusive and values-based recruiting culture remains key when it comes to attracting employees who align with your organization’s mission. With human stewardship over AI in recruiting, the future of talent acquisition looks bright.

[On Demand] The AI-Enabled Graduate: Mastering Gen AI’s Impact on Early Careers Recruitment

Posted on September 26, 2025October 23, 2025 by akessler

[Webinar On-Demand] The AI-Enabled Graduate:

Mastering Gen AI’s Impact on Early Careers Recruitment

The early careers recruitment landscape has been fundamentally transformed. While organisations debate whether AI will impact hiring, early career job seekers are already using generative AI in their job search. This isn’t a future trend; it’s today’s reality.

Is your recruitment strategy ready for the AI-enabled graduate?

Join PeopleScout’s Head of Assessment Design, Amanda Callen, and Talent Solutions Director, James Chorley, for a data-driven session that reveals PeopleScout’s exclusive research on how Generation AI is strategically transforming early careers recruitment—and what employers must do to stay ahead.

Discover our findings that show how early career candidates are using AI throughout their recruitment journey. This isn’t speculation—it’s comprehensive research that shows why employers need to move beyond guesswork and implement proactive, transparent and adaptive recruitment strategies.

In this webinar, we’ll cover:

The scale and strategic nature of Gen AI adoption among early career job seekers
Why early careers recruitment needs to adapt to stay on top of rapid technological advancements
Why transparent communication is essential to build trust with the AI-native generation
Essential steps to review and strengthen your assessment processes against AI vulnerabilities
How to implement proactive strategies to embrace AI-enabled candidates

Plus you’ll receive:

Exclusive access to our research report, Gen AI Meets Gen Z
Assessment vulnerability checklist

What is a Staffing Agency? 7 Top Differences Between RPO and Staffing Agencies

Posted on September 26, 2025October 31, 2025 by akessler

What is a staffing agency? Organizations are facing unprecedented hiring challenges that traditional staffing agencies simply weren’t designed to solve. Between remote work, skills shortages in critical roles, and the need to compete with enterprise employers for top talent, growing companies need strategic partners, not just résumé and CV providers.

So, what is the difference between a staffing agency and an RPO solutions provider? In this, article we’ll cover the major differences between RPO and staffing agencies and how to know what’s best for your talent acquisition program.

RPO vs Staffing Agencies: What is a Staffing Agency and Which Recruitment Model is Right for You?

Recruitment process outsourcing (RPO) is a type of business process outsourcing in which an employer transfers delivery of some or all portions of the recruitment process to an external service provider. RPO is a long-term partnership or project-based solution that helps you evolve your talent acquisition strategy to attract and retain high-quality talent to meet your business goals. Outsourcing through an RPO lets you scale up or down during high and low volume periods. RPO recruitment companies can cover everything from high-volume hiring to niche roles and can be regional or cover your global hiring requirements.

Staffing Agencies operate on a transactional model, focusing on filling individual job requisitions. They maintain their own brand, work with multiple clients simultaneously on similar roles, and typically hand off candidates once initial screening is complete.

For companies, particularly small to mid-sized organizations, this distinction matters more than ever. Here’s why.

7 Critical Differences Between RPO vs Staffing Agency

1. Strategic Partnership

RPO Approach: Your RPO team acts as an extension of your in-house team and is your strategic partner in creating a talent acquisition program. RPO recruiters may sit on-site, work remotely, work offshore or a combination, and they’ll usually take on your company name and email domain in their communications. An RPO partner will come to understand your business deeply, which means they are best suited to help you evolve your talent acquisition program to meet your needs now and scale into the future, maintaining institutional knowledge and process consistency.

Staffing Agency Approach: Agency recruiters typically act as a finder—sourcing, pre-screening and introducing candidates to the client (often the hiring manager) who takes it from there. Agency recruiters keep their own company email and brand when interacting with candidates.

This works for one-off hires but breaks down when you’re scaling rapidly. Growing companies need partners who understand your long-term evolution and can anticipate your needs.

2. Process Improvements

RPO Approach: RPO partners conduct comprehensive process audits, identify inefficiencies, and implement scalable improvements. Not only does this reduce time-to-fill, but it also improves the candidate experience. A process evaluation will also include your talent technology. Your RPO partner will assess any gaps, make recommendations for new solutions and support the implementation process.

Staffing Agency Approach: For a staffing agency, the hire-by-hire nature of their work means they’re likely not looking for ways to improve your overall hiring processes. They maintain their own workflows, which can create disconnects and inconsistencies as you grow, impacting the candidate experience and your employer brand.

3. Talent Pooling

RPO Approach: One huge advantage of the long-term relationship you build with an RPO partner is taking advantage of their ability to create talent pools. Having a pool of active and passive candidates speeds up time-to-hire, because when new roles open, you’re not starting from zero.

Staffing Agency Approach: Agencies focus on finding candidates for a specific vacancy. It tends to be a reactive model, in which they work from requisition to requisition. Agency recruiters maintain a pool of candidates for their multiple clients, so these candidates are not necessarily found with your company in mind.

4. Quality + Cultural Fit

RPO Approach: Leading RPO providers offer comprehensive talent assessment solutions, using behavioral interviews, skills evaluations and cultural fit assessments. This is particularly important for small to mid-sized companies as the consequences of a bad hire are far more significant and visible than at large enterprises.

Staffing Agency Approach: Agencies focus primarily on skills and experience matching. Cultural fit assessment, when it happens, is typically limited to basic screening questions. They generally won’t be responsible for administering assessment solutions or advise on how to improve them.

5. Talent Advisory

RPO Approach: RPO partners bring added value through their expertise in talent advisory, including employer branding, recruitment marketing, candidate communications, assessment services, labor market insights, workforce planning and talent acquisition strategy. These capabilities are vital for positioning your organization to efficiently attract, recruit and retain top talent in today’s competitive hiring landscape.

Staffing Agency Approach: Agencies typically post jobs on their preferred job boards and tap their existing networks. Employer branding and recruitment marketing remain your responsibility—assuming you have the expertise internally.

6. Technology Consulting

RPO Approach: RPO providers offer technology consulting, and help you understand how you can leverage AI-powered sourcing, advanced analytics, and tech integration to improve your recruitment outcomes. Some RPO providers offer some kind of recruitment technology component, whether it’s a propriety system, like PeopleScout’s Affinix® total talent suite, or expertise in a variety of talent technology systems. They’ll be comfortable working with your existing systems and can recommend solutions that scale with your growth.

Staffing Agency Approach: Agencies use their own technology stack, which may not integrate with your systems. Limited technology means you miss out on advanced sourcing tools and market intelligence platforms.

7. Reporting and Analytics

RPO Approach: RPO providers take ownership of recruitment outcomes. They’ll work with you to define metrics, KPIs and SLAs, and report on them on a regular basis. RPO dashboards provide visibility into time-to-hire, cost-per-hire, source-of-hire, candidate or hiring manager satisfaction and retention levels. In addition, leading RPO partners bring labor market insights to help you understand the available talent pool in the locations in which you’re hiring and recommendations on how to adjust your strategy.

Staffing Agency Approach: Agency accountability typically ends when they present candidates. Limited reporting means you can’t optimize your overall hiring strategy or demonstrate ROI to leadership.

The Mid-Market Reality: Why Staffing Agencies Fall Short

The challenges facing small to mid-sized companies go far beyond what traditional staffing agencies were designed to handle:

Remote/Hybrid Talent Competition: You’re no longer competing just with local companies—you’re competing globally for remote talent. This requires sophisticated sourcing strategies and employer branding.
Skills Shortage Crisis: Critical roles in technology, healthcare, and engineering have candidate shortages of around 40%. Finding qualified candidates requires proactive pipeline development, not reactive posting.
Candidate Experience Expectations: Top talent expects streamlined, technology-enabled hiring processes. Clunky, agency-mediated experiences drive candidates to your competitors.
Rapid Scaling Requirements: Whether you’re preparing for Series B funding or geographic expansion, you need recruitment partners who can scale quickly without compromising quality.

The Bottom Line

The talent market rewards strategic thinking over transactional hiring. Organizations, particularly mid-sized companies, that treat recruitment as a competitive advantage—through RPO partnerships, technology integration, and process optimization—will outpace those still relying on traditional staffing approaches.

The question isn’t whether you need recruitment support—it’s whether you need a vendor or a strategic partner. That distinction often determines who wins the best candidates and scales most successfully.

Recruitment Marketing Analytics: From Gut Instinct to Data Intelligence

Posted on September 15, 2025September 15, 2025 by akessler

The emergence of data-driven recruitment has fundamentally transformed how forward-thinking organizations approach talent acquisition. Recruitment marketing analytics isn’t just about tracking basic metrics like application volumes or cost-per-hire—it’s about developing deep insights into candidate behavior, optimizing every stage of the talent journey, and making strategic decisions backed by concrete evidence rather than assumptions.

Leveraging the data generated through recruitment marketing represents more than just operational improvement—it’s a strategic evolution that enables talent acquisition teams to operate with the sophistication and accountability of modern marketing departments.

Recruitment Marketing Analytics Fundamentals

Modern CRM systems provide critical insights through talent pool composition analytics, engagement metrics, campaign performance measurement and conversion measurement across the candidate journey. But a recruitment analytics platform goes deeper, offering a single source of truth for understanding your end-to-end recruitment process.

Talent acquisition leaders are increasingly adopting sophisticated data-driven approaches to optimize strategies, allocate resources effectively and demonstrate clear ROI to organizational stakeholders. Look for an analytics platform with interactive dashboards that visually monitor trends and identify opportunities, connecting recruitment analytics with talent market intelligence.

Key Performance Indicators Across the Candidate Journey

Awareness:

Career site metrics: Unique visitors, source attribution, and content engagement
Social media engagement: Follower growth, share of voice, and engagement rates

Consideration:

Talent community growth: New registrations and nurture campaign engagement
Application intent: Job description views, application starts, and abandoned rates
Engagement quality: Repeat visits and time spent exploring opportunities

Application:

Conversion metrics: Application completion rates and cost-per-application
Candidate quality: Skills match percentage and diversity of applicant pool
Efficiency: Time to qualified candidate and recruitment marketing cost-per-hire

Cross-Funnel Metrics:

Candidate experience: Satisfaction surveys at various touchpoints
Market responsiveness: Time-to-fill by position and location

Advanced Analytics

Organizations that move beyond basic reporting can unlock deeper insights to transform recruitment marketing effectiveness.

Cohort Analysis: Track candidate groups over time to identify behavior patterns and evaluate the long-term impact of marketing initiatives.
Funnel Analysis: Identify conversion bottlenecks, compare performance across candidate segments, and evaluate stage-by-stage conversion efficiency to optimize the candidate journey.
Channel Effectiveness Analysis: Compare cross-channel performance, calculate return on investment by channel, and find the optimal channel mix for improved budget allocation.

Predictive Analytics and AI Applications

Predictive analytics leverages artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning to highlight insights, anomalies and predictions, including:

Candidate conversion predictions
Channel performance forecasting
Hiring timeline optimization
Sourcing strategy recommendations
Budget allocation optimization

These capabilities help talent teams understand behaviors of top talent and predict factors such as cultural fit, willingness to change companies and future tenure potential—helping to support confident recruitment marketing budgets.

Building a Culture of Data-Driven Decision Making

Successfully implementing recruitment marketing analytics requires more than just sophisticated analytics tools—it demands a fundamental shift in how talent acquisition teams approach strategy development and performance evaluation. This cultural transformation involves moving from reactive, intuition-based decisions to proactive, evidence-based strategies.

The most successful organizations establish regular data review cycles where recruitment teams analyze performance metrics, identify trends, and adjust strategies accordingly. They create accountability frameworks that tie recruitment marketing decisions to measurable outcomes, and they invest in developing analytical capabilities across their talent acquisition teams.

Equally important is establishing clear data governance practices that ensure accuracy, consistency, and actionable insights. This includes standardizing data collection methods, implementing quality control processes, and creating accessible dashboards that enable real-time monitoring and decision-making.

Recruitment Marketing Analytics as a Revenue Driver

Data-driven recruitment marketing transforms talent acquisition from a cost center focused on filling positions to a strategic function that drives measurable business value. When recruitment teams can demonstrate clear connections between their marketing investments and outcomes like improved candidate quality, faster time-to-hire, and enhanced employer brand perception, they gain credibility and resources to execute increasingly sophisticated strategies.

By adopting recruitment marketing analytics, organizations can optimize recruitment marketing budgets, improve candidate quality, reduce time-to-hire and demonstrate clear ROI to leadership—creating sustainable competitive advantages in the global talent marketplace. The future belongs to those who can transform data into actionable insights and use those insights to build more effective, efficient and candidate-centric recruitment experiences.

How Recruitment Marketing Technology Is Transforming Talent Acquisition

Posted on September 15, 2025September 15, 2025 by akessler

Today’s most successful organizations aren’t just using technology to automate existing processes—they’re leveraging it to fundamentally reimagine how they identify, attract, engage and nurture talent relationships. Modern recruitment marketing technology enables organizations to operate more sophisticated recruitment marketing campaigns, with the ability to segment audiences, personalize experiences, track engagement, measure ROI and optimize campaigns in real-time. The result is a more strategic, efficient, and candidate-centric approach that drives superior outcomes in an increasingly competitive talent market.

Understanding and leveraging these technological capabilities isn’t just an advantage—it’s becoming essential for remaining competitive in a market where the best candidates have multiple options and expect sophisticated, personalized experiences throughout their journey.

Core Capabilities of Modern CRM Platforms

While Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) have long served as the technological backbone of recruitment processes, their focus on managing active applications creates significant limitations in today’s talent-driven market. Enter Candidate Relationship Management (CRM) technology. A CRM platform enables organizations to nurture relationships with candidates long before they apply, creating robust talent pipelines and enhancing the overall candidate experience.

Talent Community Management

At the heart of CRM technology is the ability to build and nurture talent communities. A CRM allows you to create dynamic talent pools where candidates can express interest, update preferences and receive tailored communications—all outside the formal application process. Talent groups can be segmented to create region-specific or role-specific talent communities that respect nuances while maintaining a consistent employer brand.

Key Capabilities:

Segmentation capabilities for targeted engagement
Self-service profile management for candidates
Interest-based talent pool organization
Engagement tracking and scoring
Automated membership management workflows

Personalized Candidate Journeys

CRM technology helps you create the highly personalized experiences modern candidates expect. Deliver experiences that feel bespoke to each candidate, addressing their specific interests, career aspirations and information needs based on their stage in the process. For instance, a software developer might receive content about technical challenges and innovation, while a marketing professional might see content showcasing creative campaigns and brand initiatives.

Key Capabilities:

Microsites for specific talent communities or recruitment campaigns
Automated yet personalized communication workflows
Hyper-targeted messaging informed by career site behavior, engagement signals and candidate status
Preference and interest-based content delivery

Sophisticated Nurture Campaigns

Perhaps the most transformative aspect of CRM technology is the ability to develop long-term engagement strategies. This allows talent acquisition teams to maintain meaningful connections with potential candidates over extended periods, gradually building familiarity and preference for the employer brand. For roles with limited talent pools, such as specialized technical positions or senior leadership, these nurture capabilities are particularly valuable in developing relationships with passive candidates who may not be ready to apply immediately.

Advanced Features:

Multi-stage nurture campaign development
Email and SMS/text communication
Trigger-based communication sequences
Engagement scoring and qualification models
Cross-channel campaign coordination

Event Management and Engagement

CRM platforms have evolved to support comprehensive event strategies. From campus recruitment fairs to executive networking events, CRM technology provides the infrastructure to maximize the relationship-building potential of in-person and virtual interactions. The most effective platforms seamlessly integrate event engagement with broader candidate journeys, ensuring consistent experiences across touchpoints.

Functionality Includes:

Registration and attendance management
Pre- and post-event communication sequences
Virtual event platform integration
Attendee engagement tracking
ROI measurement for recruitment events

Creating a Unified Recruitment Ecosystem

The true power of recruitment technology emerges not from individual tools, but from their seamless integration. A well-integrated technology stack enables consistent candidate experience, streamlines workflows and comprehensive data analysis. For example, integrating your CRM with your ATS eliminates the “black hole” experience where candidates lose visibility into the their status after applying. Instead, the CRM maintains the relationship regardless of application outcomes, enabling you to maintain connections with promising candidates for future opportunities.

The Power of One

Consider leveraging a talent technology suite—a tech platform that integrates an ATS, a CRM and recruitment marketing capabilities out-of-the-box. For example, Affinix®, PeopleScout’s proprietary total talent suite, brings your entire recruitment journey together into one ecosystem. Affinix connects applicant tracking, candidate relationship management, recruitment marketing, digital interviewing and talent analytics with a consistent user experience across applications. Through our modular approach, you can mix and match capabilities and build the perfect recruitment ecosystem for your needs.

The Data Advantage of Recruitment Marketing Technology

Modern recruitment marketing technology generates unprecedented insights into candidate behavior, campaign effectiveness and talent market dynamics. Organizations that effectively leverage this data gain significant competitive advantages through evidence-based decision making and continuous optimization.

The most sophisticated platforms provide recruitment marketing analytics on engagement rates, conversion metrics, candidate journey progression, and sourcing effectiveness. This data enables recruitment teams to identify what’s working, optimize underperforming campaigns, and allocate resources more effectively. More importantly, it allows them to understand candidate preferences and behaviors at a granular level, informing more targeted and effective engagement strategies.

Advanced analytics also enable predictive capabilities, helping organizations anticipate talent needs, identify optimal recruitment timing, and proactively build talent pipelines before urgent hiring needs arise. This shift from reactive to proactive talent acquisition represents a fundamental evolution in how organizations approach talent strategy.

Future-Proofing Your Strategy with Recruitment Marketing Technology

As technology continues to evolve, the organizations that thrive will be those that view their recruitment marketing technology as a strategic asset rather than just operational infrastructure. The most successful organizations approach recruitment marketing technology as an integrated ecosystem that supports their employer brand, candidate experience and talent acquisition goals. By thoughtfully selecting, integrating, and optimizing their technology stack, they create powerful capabilities that drive competitive advantage in the race for talent.

Video: What is RPO?

Posted on September 12, 2025 by akessler

What is RPO?

[On Demand] New Rules for a New Reality: Early Careers Assessment for Tomorrow’s Workforce

Posted on August 11, 2025 by akessler

[Webinar On-Demand] New Rules for a New Reality

Early Careers Assessment for Tomorrow’s Workforce

The early careers recruitment landscape has been turned upside down. With hiring volumes slashed, companies are inundated with hundreds of applications for just a handful of positions. Sprinkle in some Gen AI, and it’s a whole new game.

Is it time to throw away the old early careers recruitment rulebook?

Join PeopleScout’s Head of Assessment Design, Amanda Callen, and Talent Solutions Director, James Chorley, for an eye-opening session that reveals how TMP Worldwide partnered with PeopleScout Psychologists to rewrite the rules and create a future-ready approach for early careers assessment.

Discover how they built their bold new assessment model from scratch, processing massive applicant volumes while being budget-friendly and genuinely engaging. Built to be Gen AI-resilient, highly inclusive, and perfectly tailored to attract creative talent, this wasn’t about playing it safe; it was about having the courage to build something entirely new.

In this webinar, we’ll cover:

How to identify which “rules” in early careers assessment are actually worth following in 2025 and beyond
Modern strategies for efficiently sifting through massive applicant volumes to uncover hidden gems
Practical approaches for building evidence-based, bespoke assessment processes
The daring design features that made TMPW’s assessment a standout success
How to create an early careers assessment that’s not just fit for the future—but ahead of it

Beyond the Beaten Pathway: Creative Assessment for TMP Worldwide’s Emerging Talent Search

Posted on August 11, 2025August 11, 2025 by akessler

Graduate Assessment

Beyond the Beaten Pathway: Creative Assessment for TMP Worldwide’s Emerging Talent Search

Discover how PeopleScout designed an innovative graduate assessment process for TMP Worldwide’s new development programme. Our reciprocal choice model, Gen AI-resilient tools, and bespoke selection stages that achieved 100% offer acceptance while identifying future leaders who aligned with company values.

100 % attendance rate for the assessment centre

100 % offer acceptance rate

Gen AI resilient assessment process

Situation

TMP Worldwide—a transformative, multi-award-winning advertising agency that dominates UK media buying, employer branding, recruitment marketing, and resourcing—had big plans. They’d created a brand-new two-year graduate development programme designed to cultivate their next generation of leaders. The catch? Just three coveted spots were available.

While TMPW had successfully designed and delivered numerous graduate assessment processes for their clients, this was the first time TMPW was running a scheme of their own. Unlike a typical graduate scheme with rigid degree requirements or university hierarchies, TMPW’s Graduate Pathway was designed to find graduates with a different mindset who could maximise every learning opportunity and emerge as genuine trailblazers.

They were working with shorter-than-usual timescales and needed maximum return on investment. The challenge was on to design and deliver a bespoke, forward-focused and cost-efficient early careers assessment process to unearth three brilliant graduates.

With no historical data to lean on and an evolving early careers landscape, the process had to be flexible enough to scale up or down based on unknown application volumes—all without affecting costs or timelines. Plus, they needed to stay ahead of the curve with Gen-AI-aware design features that would protect the process from unwanted disruption from candidates potentially using Gen AI to exaggerate or misrepresent their skills.

Solution

PeopleScout’s Assessment Psychologists crafted a bespoke, end-to-end selection process that brought TMPW’s unique proposition to life. This wasn’t about adapting existing frameworks—this was industry-first thinking that gave candidates multiple opportunities to showcase their strengths through an engaging, informative experience.

We started from scratch, applying best practice design principles with a creative twist. We began with research to capture the expertise and perspectives of key Graduate Pathway stakeholders to build a values-led assessment framework that truly embodied TMPW’s culture.

The Reciprocal Choice Revolution

Here’s where our different mindset really showed. Instead of the traditional one-way selection approach, we developed an innovative reciprocal choice model based on TMP’s values and candidates’ evolving expectations. This creative solution emphasised mutual fit over one-sided evaluation, embedding informed candidate choice throughout the process and prioritising transparent, authentic two-way communication between candidate and company.

We integrated realistic job preview (RJP) elements at every stage, ensuring candidates could make genuinely informed decisions about their future with TMP.

We recognised the potential for Gen-AI-enabled applicants to impact the accuracy of hiring decisions and were transparent with candidates about AI usage and issued training and guidance to recruiters.

Three Stages of Discovery

Our creative approach unfolded across four carefully designed stages, each providing deeper insights into both the programme and TMPW while enabling candidates to self-assess their alignment with the company.

Stage 1: Killer Questions

We kicked off with strategically crafted questions based on realistic job previews and informed choice principles. This wasn’t about catching people out—it was about helping the right candidates identify themselves early.

Stage 2: Gen AI-Resilient Sift

Our Gen AI-resilient sift tool assessed priority criteria from the framework, using autoscored situational and preference questions specifically designed to limit Gen AI disruption. This ensured we were evaluating genuine responses and different thinking styles.

Stage 3: Asynchronous Video Interview

We invited the highest-scoring candidates to pre-record a video interview. Those who gave personalised, unique responses earned their place at our immersive assessment centre at TMPW’s London headquarters.

Stage 4: Immersive, Work-Sampling Assessment Centre

This final stage provided realistic work samples and genuine previews of life at TMPW and the nature of role, testing holistic match and ensuring successful candidates could make fully informed decisions when it came to accepting offers—fulfilling our goal to make the right hires the first time and every time.

Results

Interest in the pathway was huge, and our creative solution delivered exactly what TMPW needed. With automated sifting, asynchronous video interviews, and extensive self-assessment opportunities, we identified candidates who were both exceptionally talented and genuinely motivated to succeed at TMPW.

TMPW were overwhelmingly happy with what we managed to achieve, including:

Maintaining a highly diverse candidate pool through to the assessment centre.
Highly eligible assessment centre candidates who scored highly across the full set of assessment criteria during the exercises and interviews.
Cost-effective use of only bespoke-designed assessments with no cost-per-use or licence costs, as well as the ability to scale up without increasing costs.
100% attendance rate for the assessment centre.
100% offer acceptance rate.
Positive feedback on the assessment experience from candidates.
The identification of strong future leaders who aligned with TMP’s company values and unique culture.

This industry-first approach didn’t just fill three graduate positions—it created a blueprint for identifying and attracting different thinkers who’ll drive competitive advantage for TMPW and their clients for years to come.

Candidate Feedback:

“I enjoyed how immersive and hand-on the process was. There were lots of different styles of tasks.”
“The process was very creative and unique.”

At a Glance

COMPANY
TMP Worldwide UK
INDUSTRY
Consulting
About TMP Worldwide
TMP Worldwide UK is a leading recruitment marketing agency, specialising in connecting top talent with employers through innovative and data-driven solutions. With decades of experience in the talent acquisition space, TMP Worldwide UK helps employers to attract, engage, and retain the best candidates. Focused on driving measurable results through strategic employer branding, recruitment advertising, and recruitment technology, TMP Worldwide UK helps organisations to outthink their competitors and build stronger, more diverse workforces. For more information, please visit www.tmpw.co.uk. TMP Worldwide UK is part of PeopleScout, a TrueBlue (NYSE: TBI) company, a global talent solutions leader that provides unmatched scalability to meet the hiring needs of organisations of all sizes.

Contact Sales

How an Art Heist Transformed Financial Services Recruitment

Posted on July 11, 2025July 11, 2025 by akessler

PeopleScout Assessment

How an Art Heist Transformed Financial Services Recruitment

PeopleScout’s assessment and creative teams helped a leading financial services company transform their entry-level recruitment process from a typical interview to an innovative, immersive experience, creating an assessment centre unlike any candidate had encountered before.

86 % assessment centre pass rate (up from 41%)

98 % offer acceptance rate (up from 73%)

98 % candidate satisfaction scores after the assessment

Situation

A leading financial services provider, specialising in pensions, investments and insurance, was facing recruitment challenges. They needed to fill contact centre roles—mainly phone-based positions handling customer inquiries—but their process needed a revamp.

The numbers tell the story: In 2023, the company processed approximately 7,000 applications to fill 250 entry-level positions. That’s a mountain of CVs and a serious administrative burden. Their approach was pretty standard—online application, a telephone interview followed by a face-to-face competency interview. They’d assess just 12 to 14 candidates per day, running two interviews simultaneously, seven times a day.

In addition to the scale of the effort, hiring managers kept gravitating toward candidates who already had contact centre or financial services experience. The client’s talent acquisition team spotted this bias and realised they were probably missing out on brilliant people who hadn’t worked in these specific areas before. These candidates might have exactly what it takes to excel—they just didn’t tick the “industry experience” box.

So, they decided it was time for a complete recruitment makeover.

Solution

We stepped in to flip the client’s assessment approach on its head, creating something that was fair, inclusive, and—dare we say it—actually fun.

Our psychologists teamed up with our creative team to figure out how to support evidence-based hiring decisions while giving candidates an experience they’d never forget. What emerged was a multi-stage, immersive assessment that aligned with the client’s goals and gave everyone a fair shot.

Assessment Framework Development

Our psychologists rolled up their sleeves and did a deep-dive job analysis, systematically reviewing multiple information sources to define the capabilities, experience, skills, abilities and behaviours that make someone successful in these contact centre roles. They talked to hiring managers, incumbents and recruiters to understand what “good” really looks like—not just on paper, but in practice—securing stakeholder buy-in and support throughout the process.

From the research an assessment framework was created which guided the design of all the assessments. This research-driven approach meant the assessment process was built on best practice methodology while actually measuring what mattered for job performance. Our goal was to achieve:

A standardised assessment process ensures all candidates have the same experience, enhancing equality, diversity, and inclusion (ED&I) and increasing fairness
Objective assessment of candidates, focusing on evidence-based criteria that are relevant to job performance
Concrete, evidence-based rationale for hiring decisions, ensuring fair, accurate and defensible outcomes

Three-Stage Assessment Process

Our psychologists designed a multi-method assessment process to offer candidates multiple opportunities to shine. By mixing different types of assessments, we could accommodate different strengths and preferences while reducing bias—accommodating neurominority candidates and accounting for different preferences for showcasing abilities.

The three-stage process cleverly blended automated scoring with human insight, cutting down on bias while saving assessors’ time.

Stage 1: Telephone Screen

The client wanted to keep their phone interview—it was working well for them. So, our psychologists took what they had and made it better, creating standardised questions and scoring while keeping the motivational elements and assessing behaviours from the assessment framework.

Stage 2: Online Assessment

Here’s where we got bold: we ditched the CVs entirely. To reduce the likelihood of decisions being based on work history, we developed a gamified online assessment that tested the core behaviours we’d identified as crucial for success.

Working with the client’s test publisher, our psychologists advised on aligning their gamified assessment to the assessment framework, creating an automated sift stage ahead of the assessment centre which boosted pipeline efficiency. The highest scorers moved forward, regardless of their background—saving time and boosting objectivity.

Stage 3: Immersive Assessment Centre

Candidates were expecting a standard, corporate assessment process. But, with the assessment centre invitation they received a video that parachuted them into an alternative world where—for one day only—they became part of a fictional organisation, an underground resistance movement tasked with stopping ruthless art thieves from pulling off the art heist of the century.

Within this world, candidates did an interview, a mock customer conversation exercise to understand customer-facing roles, and a group exercise with clues and problem-solving tasks.

We dressed the assessment room and utilised themed props—ticket stubs, Instagram posts, umbrellas, and even a Magic 8 ball—creating an assessment experience unlike any they had encountered before.

The candidates worked together to solve puzzles and piece together clues. The high-energy, creative challenges included finding criminal targets, cracking cryptic codes, locating target artwork and galleries, and responding to the intel of a double agent. All of it was woven into a cinematic experience delivered by professional actors.

The whole assessment centre was anchored in science and a robust assessment framework—all within just two hours.

By creating this fantasy world full of brain-teasing challenges and tasks, candidates had such a good time they relaxed and brought their true selves to the event. As a result, the in-room assessors could then use the scoring guides to easily identify the core attributes the client was looking for in its recruits.

“The highlight was seeing them laughing and interacting as a team during the group assessment. It was almost like they forgot they were interviewing for a job.”
Talent Acquisition Leader

To ensure the success of the assessment centre, we provided comprehensive training and clear assessment guides for managers, assessors, and facilitators, ensuring they understood assessment best practices and had a detailed briefing of the exercises themselves.

Results

In the first four months of assessment centres, we achieved:

0% “no show” rate (down from 25%)
86% assessment centre pass rate (up from 41%)
98% offer acceptance rate (up from 73%)
60% attrition, now at the lowest rate since the pandemic
37 days in recruiter time saved since removing CVs from the pre-assessment centre stage
98% candidate satisfaction rate at the end of the assessment centre
92% new joiner satisfaction rate

Importantly, candidates who received offers came from a variety of backgrounds, including nail technicians, chefs, employees from a world-famous golf course and a football club, and former retirees returning to work.

Candidate Feedback:

“The best interview experience I’ve had.”

“I forgot I was being assessed.”

“I have never had an interview experience with this much human touch.”

“The best one I have done. The others were old school and formulaic.”

“The playfulness was different level.”

“It’s nice to be tested on ‘you’ rather than experiences you may have been fortunate or unfortunate to have gone through.”

“I’ve been bragging about how much fun it was.”

Client Feedback:

“Our new immersive assessment process sees us shift immediately from an old-fashioned, competency-based interview to a modern selection process focused on behaviours, underpinned by robust occupational science. We’ll jump from lagging behind our peers, to a market leading proposition that will ultimately see us making better informed hiring choices. Results so far have been really encouraging, and it’s been great to see such positive initial feedback from our managers and candidates.” – Talent Acquisition Leader

“It was a new refreshing way to carry out recruitment, and one I think will bring in the right people. I enjoyed the interview section as I felt like the questions were much more suited to what we are looking for. I also felt the role plays were great as it gave us a real insight into the candidates’ customer service skills. Overall, I felt it was a big success and look forward to doing the next recruitment day.” – Hiring Manager

“The role play gave an insight into the candidates’ behaviours which is the most important thing. The group exercise really allowed people to immerse themselves into the exercise, and I feel we saw their true colours.” – Hiring Manager

At a Glance

COMPANY
Financial service company
INDUSTRY
Banking & Financial Services
PEOPLESCOUT SOLUTIONS
Recruitment Process Outsourcing, Talent Advisory

Let’s Connect

Is Skills-Based Hiring Really the Next Big Thing?

Posted on July 11, 2025July 11, 2025 by akessler

In the recruitment space, skills-based hiring is on the tip of talent acquisition leaders’ tongues. Is it worthy of all the ink spilled or just the flavour of the month?

The internet is buzzing with headlines framing skills-based hiring as a revolutionary step forward—a clean break from “outdated” methods like focusing on academic qualifications. But as usual, we want to take a more critical look.

Let’s step away from the hype to examine the real pros and cons of skills-based hiring. More importantly, let’s figure out how skills-based hiring can work for you.

Skills-Based Hiring: Is it Really New?

There are three common myths being perpetuated by many of the articles about skills-based hiring:

Myth 1: Educational qualifications have been the main barrier to good hiring decisions.

The argument goes that recruiting teams rely too heavily on degrees and don’t think enough about skills—and if they just focused on skills instead, all their hiring issues would be solved.

This misrepresents how most employers actually make hiring decisions. While education requirements do exist in job descriptions, they’re rarely the primary factor in final hiring choices. Most recruiters already consider multiple factors including experience, cultural fit and demonstrated abilities. Skills-based hiring has its positives and certainly feels more inclusive than rigid degree requirements, but it’s not the revolutionary shift from degree-obsessed hiring that many articles suggest.

Myth 2: Everyone talking about skills is talking about the same thing.

One reason the history of skills-based hiring is hard to track is the absence of a clear, consistent definition of what constitutes a “skill.” In the context of skills-based hiring, a skill could be a competency, strength or motivation—anything that enables a person to do the job well. That landscape is far more nuanced and complex than most articles let on.

The reality is that defining skills is a lengthy process and requires careful consideration of context. But most writers on this subject don’t bother to grapple with this complexity. Instead, they gloss over any real explanation of what skills are, feeding the perception that skills are so simple and universally understood that we don’t need definitions. This creates the illusion that organizations should be able to easily incorporate skills-based approaches without doing the hard work of actually defining what they mean by “skills” in their specific context.

Myth 3: Skills-based hiring and talent management is a new idea, and the bandwagon is leaving the station.

Headlines will have you believe that skills-based hiring is “the next big thing” and a silver bullet that will solve all your workforce woes. However, this doesn’t really reflect most hiring processes.

Even if you’re not actively thinking about skills-based hiring, it’s likely that it is embedded—at least partly—into your hiring process already. Today, recruiters rarely just think in terms of hiring somebody because their qualifications line up to the “essential” section of the job description.

So, skills-based hiring isn’t a new idea. The term might be, but not the practice.

These myths lead us to feel that the noise around skills-based hiring is misleading. It suggests that skills-based hiring is driving the recruitment industry right now, when in reality, very few are moving forward with it in an overt, intentional way.

Getting Started with Skills-Based Hiring When Time and Budgets Aren’t Huge

If you do want to embrace skills-based hiring, here are some practical steps:

1. Start with an Audit

If you’re keen to implement skills-based hiring, first of all, feel reassured that it’s likely already part of your approach, even if you don’t call it that. Start by establishing where you are along the skills-based continuum.

Diagnostics come into their own here. Assess your hiring processes in a structured way, identifying gaps, strengths and opportunities for improvement. It can be beneficial to bring in an external partner like the PeopleScout Assessment Design team, to provide robust, evidence-based, unbiased feedback to maximise impact.

2. Defining Your Skills

Then it comes down to defining skills—for now and the future. These can’t be vague; they need to be carefully defined so that they can be accurately applied. You’ll build these from research, both internally and by looking externally. If you want to have an organisation-wide approach, you’ll need to consider skills relevant for leadership and entry level roles and across departments. Engage your department heads and hiring managers to map these.

3. Look at Your Non-Skills Criteria

You don’t have to remove looking at academic qualifications from your hiring process entirely. However, if there are instances where you’re using an academic qualification as a stand-in for a skill—say, a humanities degree as a signifier of good written communication skills—you can probably move away from it and start focusing more explicitly on the skill itself.

Skills-based hiring can open doors for many candidates—and expand your talent pool. Perhaps your ideal candidate did not go to university, but their written communication skills are more than adequate for the role.

4. Kick Off a Pilot

Even without a big budget to fund an overhaul of your recruitment processes, it’s still possible to make a start. To make it manageable, begin with a small, pilot process. Your audit can help you identify the best starting point—perhaps it’s a particular department or role type.

Once you’ve started, you’ll want to closely monitor it to ensure that the benefits are genuine. Try not to feel pressured into investing too much time, money and resources into skills-based hiring because it is a hot topic. Make changes bit by bit, turn to evidence, and stay reflective.

The Bottom Line

Don’t get overcome by buzzwords. In all likelihood, skills-based hiring has been a part of your process for a while now. If you want to concentrate more on skills-based hiring, start small, remain sceptical of the hype, get external insight, be evidence-based and keep evolving your approach.