PeopleScout Jobs Report Analysis—March 2024

U.S. employers added 303,000 jobs in March, far exceeding expectations and demonstrating the continued resistance of the U.S. labor market. Significant job gains were seen in healthcare, reflecting the surging demand from the aging baby boomer population, and leisure and hospitality, where job numbers have finally returned to pre-pandemic levels. Unemployment fell slightly to 3.8%. Year-over-year wage growth rose to 4.1%. 

The Numbers 

303,000: U.S. employers added 303,000 jobs in March.  

3.8%: The unemployment rate fell to 3.8%.  

4.1%: Wages rose 4.1% over the past year.  

The Good 

U.S. employers added 303,000 jobs in March, far exceeding expectations and demonstrating the continued resilience of the U.S. labor market. Thus far, 2024 average monthly job gains have exceeded those prior to the pandemic. According to MarketWatch, the strength of the labor market is causing some economists to reconsider their predictions of an economic slowdown. As noted by the New York Times, the March report shows remarkable improvement from this time last year, when most financial analysts predicted a recession was just months away. There has also been an increase in labor participation, which the Fed and many economists attribute in part to immigration, which should help sustain strong job growth and maintain a balance between labor supply and demand. 

The Bad 

Growth in year-over-year average hourly earnings slowed to 4.1%, down from 4.3% in February, the slowest annual pace since June 2021. While job growth remains strong, it has been concentrated in a few sectors, with two-thirds of this month’s gains falling within leisure and hospitality, healthcare and government. While job growth accelerates in some industries, rate-sensitive sectors like manufacturing, warehousing and transportation and financial services appear to remain cautious about hiring as they wait on anticipated rate cuts by the Fed. According to the New York Times, other economic indicators show Americans might be feeling the pinch of continued high prices and interest rates. Consumers are pulling back on discretionary spending and more borrowers have been falling behind on credit card and loan payments.  

The Unknown 

This “eye-popping” report has experts guessing about what it means for interest rates. As reported by CNN, according to projections from their meeting last month, most Fed officials expect to cut rates at least three times this year. But with inflation above the Fed’s 2% target and all signs pointing to an incredibly strong labor market, the timing of those cuts remains uncertain. As reported by the Wall Street Journal, Fed Chair Jerome Powell and other officials have suggested that inflation data over the coming months will be more important in determining the timing of cuts. The consistent message from the Federal Reserve has been that more time is needed to see how the data unfolds—the March report is unlikely to alter their “wait-and-see” approach.  

Conclusion 

Many have found little to criticize in the better-than-expected March jobs report, with hiring, total employment, participation and weekly earnings all exceeding expectations. But Americans are still facing the reality of stubborn inflation and sustained rate increases and there’s little urgency among the Fed to lower rates anytime soon. 

PeopleScout Jobs Report Analysis—February 2024

U.S. employers added 275,000 jobs in February, outpacing expectations and exceeding January’s gain, illustrating that the labor market remains strong despite high interest rates, inflation and slowing economic indicators.  Unemployment rose to 3.9%, the highest rate since January 2022. Year-over-year wage growth rose to 4.3%. 

The Numbers 

275,000: U.S. employers added 275,000 jobs in February.  

3.9%: The unemployment rate rose to 3.9%.  

4.3%: Wages rose 4.3% over the past year.  

The Good 

February’s jobs report outpaced expectations and even exceeded January’s adjusted gain of 229,000 jobs, marking the third straight month of seasonally adjusted gains over 200,000 and the 38th consecutive month of growth, as reported by the New York Times. While January’s numbers caused concerns among economists and investors that price pressures were resurfacing, the Labor Department made substantial changes to those numbers with the release of the February report, reducing those fears. Confidence is growing among investors as the U.S. economy continues to show resilience against the highest interest rates in over 20 years while delivering consistent job growth and some of the lowest unemployment rates in recent history. Another positive sign can be seen in labor force participation rates, which jumped to 83.5% for people in their prime working years—ages 25 to 54. 

The Bad 

Despite the headline job growth numbers exceeding expectations, experts are seeing signs of a gradual slowdown. The overall unemployment rate rose to 3.9%, the highest it’s been since January 2022, and wage growth slowed. The increase in unemployment from 3.7% in January was driven by people losing or leaving jobs as well as an increase in individuals entering the labor force. As reported by the Wall Street Journal, even though the index is elevated compared to prepandemic levels, the labor market is likely to cool off, with modest job gains expected through Q3 and Q4 of 2024. 

The Unknown 

The Federal Reserve is keeping an eye on the labor market as it contemplates potential changes to interest rates. Fed officials meet on March 19-20 and are expected to leave rates unchanged at that time. If job growth remains steady and the labor market is so strong that wages rise quickly, price increases are likely to persist as companies try to cover their costs. However, if the job market begins to slow significantly, the Fed may consider earlier interest rate cuts.  

Conclusion 

The February jobs report paints the picture of a labor market that is gradually downshifting with steady hiring and cooling wage growth increasing the likelihood that the U.S. will achieve a “soft landing” and bring inflation down without a recession. Moderate job and pay gains suggest the economy will continue to expand without the risk of reaccelerating inflation, giving the Federal Reserve the confidence they’re seeking to cut rates this year. 

PeopleScout Jobs Report Analysis—January 2024

U.S. employers added 353,000 jobs in January, nearly doubling what economist had predicted and demonstrating employers’ willingness to keep hiring to meet steady consumer spending. The unemployment rate remained flat at 3.7% despite predictions of a slight increase. Year-over-year wage growth rose to 4.5%. 

The Numbers 

353,000: U.S. employers added 353,000 jobs in January.  

3.7%: The unemployment rate remained unchanged at 3.7%.  

4.5%: Wages rose 4.5% over the past year.  

The Good 

January’s jobs report defied expectations with job growth nearly doubling forecasts, the unemployment rate holding steady and wages outpacing predictions. Experts at The Wall Street Journal also point out that while the bulk of hiring in 2023 came from just three sectors: government, healthcare, and restaurants and hotels, job gains in January broadened, with nearly two-thirds of private sector industries adding to their payroll or keeping them steady. January’s report adds to months of data showing that economic growth is remaining stable, if not accelerating. And after being hit hard by inflation, Americans are finally starting to feel better about the economy, according to a University of Michigan survey which showed a 29% improvement in consumer sentiment compared to November 2023, the biggest two-month increase since 1991.  

The Bad 

With few signs of weakness, the January report was described by many as universally positive. Yet, some analysts have argued that after such a big rally, further gains will be more difficult to come by. Further, despite markets buoying, stock gains did not extend across the entire market, with shares of smaller companies falling in general. These businesses may continue to suffer if the Fed takes longer to cut rates, which as reported by the New York Times, they are now in no hurry to do.  

The Unknown 

January jobs reports have been somewhat hard to read since the onset of the pandemic. While job gains have consistently been above economist’s expectations for the past few years, some believe that may be the result of shifts in seasonal hiring patterns, according to The Wall Street Journal. Further, recent high-profile layoffs from companies like UPS signal for some that demand for workers may cool in the coming months, but for now as reported by Bloomberg, there’s still plenty of evidence that employers are still hiring.  

Conclusion 

For months, U.S. jobs data has pointed to a gradually cooling labor market, which along with receding inflation led experts to believe the Fed would start cutting interest rates in early 2024. However, this “blockbuster” January report has turned that narrative on its head, suggesting a reacceleration that is likely to delay any rate cuts, at least for the time being.  

[Webinar On-Demand] The Ticking Talent Clock: Is Time Running Out to Address the Skills Crisis?

[Webinar On-Demand] The Ticking Talent Clock: Is Time Running Out to Address the Skills Crisis?

With the rapid advancement of AI, accelerated digitalization and the greening of the economy, businesses are grappling with the changing nature of work—how we work and the types of jobs we do. In fact, a new research report from PeopleScout and Spotted Zebra, The Skills Crisis Countdown, reveals that nine in 10 HR leaders believe that up to half of their workforce will need new skills to perform their jobs in the next five years. Yet, only less than one in 10 say they are actively investing in reskilling programs.

Are HR leaders running out of time?

Join PeopleScout’s Global Head of Talent Consulting Simon Wright and Spotted Zebra’s Chief Customer Officer Nick Shaw as they delve into the key findings from the research, lay bare the skills crisis and show why the clock is ticking for HR leaders.

In the webinar, Simon and Nick cover:

  • How organizations are addressing the mismatch in skills demand and supply
  • The current state of skills utilization, skills-based hiring and the need to expand talent pools
  • Strategies for improving talent mobility (including case studies and success stories)
  • Practical steps you can take to transition to a skills-focused model
  • And more!

 

PeopleScout Jobs Report Analysis—December 2023 

U.S. employers added 216,000 jobs in December, exceeding economists’ expectations and fueling optimism that the economy can achieve a so-called soft landing. The unemployment rate remained flat at 3.7%. Year-over-year wage growth rose slightly to 4.1%.

The Numbers

216,000: U.S. employers added 216,000 jobs in December. 

3.7%: The unemployment rate remained unchanged at 3.7%. 

4.1%: Wages rose 4.1% over the past year. 

The Good

December’s jobs report shows a pace of hiring even stronger than expected, wrapping up a year of steady gains in what experts at The Wall Street Journal call “a job market that continues to defy expectations.” The addition of 216,000 jobs suggests a healthy economy, with the most significant growth seen in the healthcare, leisure and hospitality, and government sectors. The unemployment rate held steady at 3.7 percent, despite analyst predictions of a slight bump over last month.

The Bad

Despite overall job growth, losses in transportation and warehousing indicate sector-specific challenges that could be a sign of shifting consumer behavior or technological advancements impacting these industries. Further, the labor force shrank by nearly 700,000 workers in December, which as reported by the New York Times is disappointing after seeing strong labor force growth through much of 2023. This decrease is likely what caused the unemployment rate to remain flat.

The Unknown

Last month’s job gains have diminished previous hopes of an interest rate cut in March, with Bloomberg reporting experts now predict the rate cut is more likely to come in May. Time will tell if additional data will help convince the Fed that inflation is still falling as hoped. According to the New York Times, Federal Reserve officials have also indicated that wage increases above 4 percent are “a little too hot for comfort,” so December’s wage gains are also likely to keep them on watch.  

Conclusion

The December 2023 U.S. jobs report indicated that the economy avoided a recession last year, and experts think it’s likely to continue to grow through 2024 as labor market resilience supports consumer spending. However, this growth is likely to delay cuts in interest rates by the Fed, keeping them on the sidelines longer than expected.

PeopleScout Jobs Report Analysis—November 2023

U.S. employers added 199,000 jobs in November, continuing the slowing pace of hiring. This is only slightly higher than what economists expected and shows the Federal Reserve’s plan to increase interest rates may be working. The unemployment rate fell to 3.7%. Year-over-year wage growth fell to 4.0%.

jobs report infographic

The Numbers

199,000: U.S. employers added 199,000 jobs in November.

3.7%: The unemployment rate fell to 3.7%.

4%: Wages rose 4% over the past year.

The Good

Experts at The Wall Street Journal call November’s jobs report “nearly perfect,” and an indication that a soft-landing for the U.S. economy is taking shape. The 199,000 jobs added to the economy represent a sustainable pace of growth that has remained steady throughout the fall months. The unemployment rate also fell to 3.7% after jumping to 3.9% the previous month. This had raised some red flags on Wall Street, but November’s decrease demonstrates that job growth is likely to continue into 2024. Additionally, wage growth continued to soften, dropping to 4%. The Federal Reserve is looking for wage growth to slow to lower inflation.

The Bad

It’s not easy to find bad news in November’s report, but the New York Times points out that the job growth was not evenly spread across industries. The strongest growth was in healthcare and government hiring, which are two of the sectors least connected to the strength of the economy. While manufacturing did see growth in December, much of that can be attributed to workers returning after the auto strikes. Additionally, the retail industry shed more than 38,000 jobs, showing some weakness in holiday hiring.

The Unknown

The big question is what the latest jobs report trends will mean for interest rates. Marketwatch reports that the Federal Reserve is likely to keep rates high into next spring. However, as the board meets next week, analysts expect the pause on increases to continue. Recent jobs reports have indicated that their strategy is working, and they fear raising rates too high or too quickly could trigger a downturn.  

PeopleScout Jobs Report Analysis—October 2023

U.S. employers added 150,000 jobs in October, showing a slowdown after a summer of strong job growth. This is lower than what economists expected and shows the Federal Reserve plan to increase interest rates may be working. The unemployment rate rose slightly to 3.9%. Year-over-year wage growth fell to 4.1%.

The Numbers

150,000: U.S. employers added 150,000 jobs in October.

3.9%: The unemployment rate fell to 3.9%.

4.1%: Wages rose 4.1% over the past year.

The Good

According to the Wall Street Journal, October’s report is the clearest sign we’ve seen that the Federal Reserve strategy of raising interest rates to slow the job market and control inflation may be working. Throughout the summer, job growth remained strong, consistently outperforming analyst expectations. The latest numbers fall into a more sustainable rate of growth. Additionally, wage growth appears to be slowing. Over the past 12 months, year-over-year wage growth has been as high as 4.8%, which makes October’s 4.1% encouraging.

The Bad

While the U.S. saw overall job growth, several industries contracted last month. Some of the most significant losses were in the manufacturing, transportation and warehousing sectors. Although, as the New York Times reported, some of this can be explained by ongoing strikes, particularly in the auto industry. Another concerning sign is that labor force participation decreased in October, shrinking the labor force by 201,000 people. Though experts say not to read too much into monthly fluctuations, they will watch the labor force participation rate in the coming months.

The Unknown

With September’s blockbuster jobs report and October’s slowdown, MarketWatch reports that the U.S. economy is displaying mixed signals, but evidence is mounting that a cooldown is starting. However, experts debate exactly how it will continue to play out. Some say the economy could continue to move forward without any major bumps, just at a slower pace; while others say they’re more concerned. They tend to agree, though, that the latest report makes it less likely that the Federal Reserve will decide to raise rates again at the next meeting in December.

Food Processing Company Slashes Costs, Boosts Compliance with Contingent Workforce Tech Overhaul

Food Processing Company Slashes Costs, Boosts Compliance with Contingent Workforce Tech Overhaul

MSP – Contingent Hiring Solution

Food Processing Company Slashes Costs, Boosts Compliance with Contingent Workforce Tech Overhaul

PeopleScout helped a leading food processor centralize and streamline its contingent hiring process through targeted technology improvements resulting in $500k annual cost savings and 19% payroll spend reduction.

500 k annual cost savings
19 % reduction in payroll spend
100 % compliance audit scores

Situation 

A leading food processing company was struggling to successfully utilize its contingent labor program across all divisions of the business. The challenges spread across 67 of the organization’s locations in 23 states, where the existing business model enabled them to operate independently.

This decentralization resulted in varied spending between locations, increased compliance risk and an unequal distribution of contingent opportunities across the program. Just ten suppliers held 84% of the program spend, which drove diversity spend below 5%.

The client had also recently announced an initiative to move several satellite offices into the company headquarters, requiring contingent workers to either relocate or work remotely when possible.

On top of this, the client was experiencing reporting limitations within their existing vendor management system (VMS), challenges with an oversaturated supply base and difficulty identifying workers for unique healthcare assignments related to worker safety during the COVID-19 pandemic.

To solve these issues, the organization approached PeopleScout to create a centralized contingent hiring solution.

Solution 

PeopleScout deployed several centralized technology process improvements across all client locations. This included implementing a more robust and enhanced VMS to improve the experience for hiring managers, suppliers and project managers. The new VMS also offered better reporting and visibility into the program spend, supplier performance, requisition management, time-to-fill and more. PeopleScout also provided the client with data for competitive benchmarking. 

PeopleScout initially experienced resistance to the new process from both managers and suppliers but overcame that obstacle by highlighting benefits like cost savings, competitive rates, expedited payment terms and more.  

As the company relocated workers, PeopleScout proactively reached out to offices where contingent workers were assigned to determine if staff could work remotely and provided strategies to assist in retention and filling vacancies. 

PeopleScout also provided Talent Advisory consulting services, including onsite meetings to review the value of MSP programs and total talent management solutions, and to discuss DE&I trends and goals with the client’s DE&I taskforce.

Results 

PeopleScout’s program led to a cost savings of $500k in annual billing and reduced payroll spend by 19% while increasing diversity spend to $2.7 million. Additionally, in interviewing 333 workers, project managers maintained an overall compliance audit score of 100%. Partnerships have been established with knowledgeable suppliers to provide sourcing support for the challenging healthcare roles. 

“I am so very grateful for all that you have done and are doing for our location. You have made this very easy on this end. I truly can’t thank you enough.” 

Client Hiring Manager 

AT A GLANCE

  • COMPANY: Food Processing Company
  • PEOPLESCOUT SOLUTIONS: Managed Service Program
  • LOCATIONS: 67 locations served in 23 states

PeopleScout Jobs Report Analysis – September 2023

U.S. employers added 336,000 jobs in September. This is nearly double the job growth that analysts expected and shows that employers still have a high demand for labor. The unemployment rate remained at 3.8%. Year-over-year wage growth fell slightly to 4.2%.

u.s. jobs report september 2023 infographic

The Numbers

336,000: Employers added 336,000 jobs in September

3.8%: The unemployment rate remained steady at 3.8%.

4.2%: Wages grew 4.2% over the past year.

The Good

The best news in September’s jobs report is that the jobs added were spread across industries, according to the Wall Street Journal. Leisure and hospitality led with 96,000 new jobs as bars and restaurants finally reached pre-pandemic staffing levels. Education and health services also added a significant 70,000 new jobs, and all major jobs categories experienced growth. The report shows that hiring is not slowing, despite high interest rates and wage growth, the restarting of student loan payments and low unemployment.

The Bad

The factors that make September’s report strong are the same ones that have analysts worried. In previous months, reports have suggested the Federal Reserve’s plan to slow hiring by raising interest rates was starting to work. The latest report tells an entirely different story. As the New York Times reports, Wall Street was wary of the blockbuster report because of the influence it could have on the Fed.

The Unknown

The latest report paints a more complicated picture for the Federal Reserve as they head into their next meeting. According to MarketWatch, this is the last report the Fed will see before that meeting, and it increases the likelihood that they will decide to raise rates again this year. The Fed has two more meeting scheduled in 2023—one on October 31 to November 1 and another December 12-13. Officials say they’re increasingly convinced that the U.S. can avoid the mass layoffs and high unemployment that typically go along with high interest rates.

2023 U.S. Workforce Trends Mid-Year Report

2023 U.S. Workforce Trends Mid-Year Report

As part of our commitment to keeping you informed about the latest news in the hiring market, we are excited to share our 2023 U.S. Workforce Trends Mid-Year Report. In this report, we have analyzed the latest jobs data across various industries so you are ready to face the months ahead with a stronger staffing strategy.

The first half of the year has seen slower hiring in many industries as businesses navigate economic uncertainty. However, there is a steady demand for workers in critical sectors such as retail, manufacturing and hospitality.

Our 2023 U.S. Workforce Trends Mid-Year Report includes:

  • National job numbers for the first half of 2023

  • Workforce and wage information for several major industries

  • A breakdown of jobs experiencing notable growth

At PeopleScout, we understand the importance of having the right workforce to support your success. That’s why our report goes beyond sharing workforce data — it also offers recommendations and strategies to help you attract and retain the right workers. These insights can help your company build a strong and flexible workforce that can adapt to changing demands, seize new opportunities and ultimately thrive in today’s business landscape.